News Flash
  • All CCs/DGs are requested to check online the requisitions/vacancies sent by them to DGHRD for confirmation in Menu-Departmental Officers-HR Issues-Vacancies reported by the field formations.click here
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBEC to all officers and staff of CBEC-click here
  • Vacancies reported by the field formations.click here
  • Corrigendum to Office Order No.10/2017 dated 12.09.2017 - promotion to the post of Chemical Examiner, Gr.II - reg. click here
  • Order extending date for filing of TRAN-1 under Rule 117 has been issued. click here
  • Minutes of the राजस्वज्ञानसंगम-Annual Conference of Tax Administrators, 2017 held at New Delhi on 01-02 September, 2017 have been uploaded on ANTARANG
  • Constitution of National Anti-profiteering Authority(NAA) under GST. click here
  • The Opt-In for Composition Levy for 2017-18 is available on GST portal. The window for opting in for composition levy for 2017-18 will be open till 30th Sep midnight. It will be applicable from 1st Oct 2017. Registration of TDS service will be available on GST portal shortly.
  • CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 18/09/2017 For details click here
  • Instruction for filing of Special Leave Petition against Orders of Hon’ble High Courts staying Collection of Tax under GST. click here
  • Filling up the post of Deputy Director in Financial Intelligence Unit, India (FIU-IND), Delhi under Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue on deputation basis.click here
  • Two notifications granting exemption from registration to job workers and suppliers of handicraft goods in specified cases.click here
  • GeM- Training schedule and PPT for HoD's.click here
  • Promotion/ Transfer/ Posting order in r/o Group 'A' Officers of CRCL under CBEC.click here
  • Transfer Policy in r/o Group 'A' Officers of CRCL under CBEC.click here
  • Notifications extending filing of GSTR-1, GSTR-2, GSTR-3 and GSTR-6 have been issued.click here
  • Suggestions to be send for Draft Expenditure Budget Manual, 2017 either through mail or fax latest by 15.09.2017-click here
  • Decisions of the GST Council on Services taken in the 21st GST Council Meeting held on 9 Sept 2017. -click here
  • List of goods where changes in GST rates have been recommended by the GST Council and increase in Compensation Cess rates of motor vehicles For details click here
  • Filing of GST return click here
  • Data regarding transfer of AIOs in the Zone- to be shared by 8th Sep 2017. click here
  • "Extension of due dates for furnishing details/Returns for the months of July, 2017 and August, 2017" - click here
  • Suggestions to be send for Draft Expenditure Budget Manual, 2017.- click here
  • "CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 30/08/2017 have been uploaded".- click here
  • Circular on System based reconciliation of information furnished in FORM GSTR-1 and FORM GSTR-2 with FORM GSTR-3B has been issued.-click here
  • Notification waving late fee for July, 2017 return has been issued
  • "Notification issued for further amendment of CGST Rules".-click here
  • Important information for field formations regarding LAN infrastructure and WAN Connectivity - click here
  • Draft Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations, (CBLR) 2017 has been uploaded. For details - click here
  • Observance of Rashtriya Ekta Diwas (National Unity Day ) on 31st Oct, 2017. click here
  • Charter of Functions of DGGST For Details click here
View all

Refund / rebate

ECS subject-wise list of Central Excise cases

S No

Citation

Name of the Party

Subject Heading

1

2012 (2) ECS (116) (Tri-Mum)(150KB)

M/s Vidyut Metallics Pvt. Ltd.

Applicants availed credit in respect of the lubricating oil and the same was used thereafter the same is cleared from the factory without payment of duty. The appellant paid the duty at the asking of the Revenue. The assessment regarding the demand is not challenged by the appellants. The appellants challenge the demand by way of filing the refund claim. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case Collector of Central Excise, Kanpur Vs. Flock India Ltd. held that in the absence of challenge to the assessment order the refund is not maintainable. In the present case, as the appellants are challenging excisability of the goods which were cleared without payment of duty. In the refund application which is not permissible.

2

2012 (2) ECS ( 97) (Tri-Del)(162KB)

M/s Sheena Exports

The goods initially cleared from the factory for home consumption and thereafter exported out of India cannot be equated with the goods exported directly from the factory under bond in terms of provision of Rule 19 of Central Excise Rule

3

2012 (2) ECS (63) (Tri-Ban)(163KB)

M/s Indian Explosive Ltd.

When an assessee claims refund of duty on the basis of price variation under the price variation clause of the relevant contract subsequent to clearance of the goods, the claim, for whatever reason, cannot be allowed. Such fluctuation in price subsequent to clearance of the goods cannot affect the manufacturer's liability to pay excise duty

4

2013 (2) ECS (46) (Tri-Ahd)(109KB)

M/s Bajaj Food. Ltd

Peanut Butter manufactured is fully exempted- such goods are neither exported under bond nor under a letter of undertaking- Cenvat Credit Rules not applicable and no refund under Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules 2004 is admissible because no credit accumulation is possible in view of the provisions of Rule 6(1) of the Cenvat Credit Rules

5

2013(1) ECS (76) (Tri-Mad)(152KB)

M/s KONE Elevator India Pvt. Ltd

Uniformity of price cannot be bar for unjust enrichment. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai-II Vs. Allied Photographics India Ltd. Vs CCE, reported in 2004 (166) E.L.T 3 (S.C.) held that consistency of price of final goods of the assessee did not materially lead to the conclusion that incidence of duty had not passed on to the customers

6

2013 (2) ECS ( 86) (Tri-Del)(92KB)

M/s Malwa Cotton Spinning Mills Ltd

Once the claim does not assume character of correct claim in the eyes of law, no right accrues to the claimant from the date on which defective application was filed and an opportunity given for removal of defects is a course of natural justice to entertain proper application filed within limitation no interest can be claimed against a defective application. Only on the date when defective application is rectified and a proper application comes to record, that date is relevant date for arise of refund with, interest in case refund is delayed

7

2013 (2) ECS (49) (Tri-Del)(105KB)

M/s Berger Paints

Refund claim of education cess and S & H education was not entertainable, since Cess not payable on goods that are fully exempted from excise duty / customs duty or are cleared without payment of excise duty / customs duty (such as clearance under bond or fulfillment of certain conditions)

8

2013 (1) ECS (78) (Tri-Ahd)(153KB)

M/s Mahendra Petrochemicals Ltd

Even if the payments made by the assessee are treated as pre-deposit, they cannot claim its refund before final disposal of their appeal

9

2013 (4) ECS (7) (Bom-HC)(179KB)

M/s. Rainbow Silks & Anr.

Accumulation of Cenvat Credit on the basis of fraudulent documents.

10

2014 (1) ECS (15) (HC-All.)(215KB)

M/s. Vee Excel Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd

Rebate under Rule 18 of C.Ex. Rules, 2002 - Procedure laid down under notification 19/2004 CE(NT) dated 06.09.2004 is mandatory.

11

2014 (4) ECS (38) (Tri-Ahd)(156KB)

M/s. Parixit Industries Ltd.

Exemption not claimed at the time of assessment cannot be claimed by way of a refund claim without challenging the original assessment.

12

2014 (4) ECS (132) (Tri-Ahd)(142KB)

M/s.Mahindra Gujarat Tractors Ltd.

Limitation for Refund - Claim filed beyond the lapse of prescribed period - As per the provisions of Section 11B of the C. Ex Act, 1944 all refund claims are required to be fi led within the stipulated time limit prescribed

13

2014 ( 4) ECS (135) (Tri-Del)(106KB)

M/s. United Chain Industries

Penalty under Rule 25 of Central Excise Rules 2002 - Invoice issued without actual supply of goods for the purpose of availing Cenvat Credit. The person purporting to sell goods connot say that he is not concerned with selling of goods and has not contravened the provisions of Rule 25 ibid